The Mars Volta's sound, even live, is a little dismal, a little thick, a few too many layers of paint to get off with a nail dragged over the sheet steel surface. But it is that impenetrability that lends it heft and import.
I got to the show at the Palladium last week a little later than might have been best, (Worcester’s Palladium is to grit what Cape Cod is to sand) and was consequently in the mezzanine, in a broken seat (which was better than the torn-out seats next to me). The volume was overwhelming, and ear plugs were absolutely critical to my enjoying it.
The Mars Volta’s style makes at least the modern King Crimson seem light, airy, and even charming. They bring enough guys to win the rumble, and they succeed, with complex, interdimensional guitar and a solid threaded hub of keyboard and drums. So, what they ultimately deliver proves chambered enough, and synchronized enough, to be far from a jam band. The point of Art Rock, it seems to me, is to lift off thoroughly from the home planet and leave behind the blues and the folk and the dance step. The idea is that enough precision creates a sonic machine, a tricked-out engine of music that turns so smoothly that its strokes and cam spins are inaudible and all that’s there is the power and force of its output.
If that’s the goal, The Mars Volta has the attitude of King Crimson and Robert Fripp (wouldn’t you love to call him “Bobby” just once?), but not the ease or the certainty. The group is supremely self-important. No stage talk, no encore, just a cursory throwaway line as they finished about how great it is not everyone is into “fast food” music. But they didn’t invent arrogance in rock music, and they won’t be its final practitioners. They have the hard part settled: Their technique was very sharp. The band was on target, on note, on mark. No slop or silliness. Now their material needs to catch up. “Ummagumma” awaits “Shine On You Crazy Diamond.”
Ultimately, what I liked best about The Mars Volta is that I was there, and that they were there, and that the best part of rock -- the experiment -- can still pack a gloomy concert hall with fresh-faced kids in black T-shirts.